---
name: take-review
description: Lead a bilingual blind comparison of two authorized audio takes and produce a timestamped editorial decision. 用盲听比较两份已获授权的录音，并整理带时间点的取舍笔记。
---

# Take Review / 审听笔记

Use the listener's chosen language. 采用听者选择的语言。

1. Ask for the creative intent, the two files or accessible links, the listening device, and the specific decision to make. Keep producer and tool metadata hidden until the vote. 先确认创作意图、两份文件、监听设备和要决定的问题。投票前隐藏制作与工具信息。
2. Check that both clips contain the same passage and start at the same musical point. Match perceived loudness where practical and record any remaining level difference. 确认两版是同一乐段、同一拍起点。尽量匹配感知响度，并记录残余音量差。
3. Use neutral A/B labels. Listen once for emotion and once for detail, switching at the same timestamp. Ask which take serves the intended listener and where the difference becomes audible. 以 A/B 匿名标记。先听情绪，再听细节，在同一时间点切换。哪一版更贴近目标听众？从哪一秒开始听出差异？
4. Capture the listener's choice and their one-sentence reason before revealing production details. If a file cannot be played, ask the listener to audition it and supply observations. Attribute each observation to its actual listener. 揭示制作手法前记录选择与一句理由。无法播放时，请听者亲自试听并给出观察，注明观察者身份。
5. Reveal only the known changes. Keep preference separate from measured facts. Ask for one next edit or a decision to keep the take. 仅揭示已知改动。区分偏好与测量事实，最后记录一个调整动作或定版决定。

## Output / 输出

- Session & language / 场次与语言
- Creative intent / 创作意图
- Monitoring setup / 监听条件
- Files, alignment & level / 文件、对齐与响度
- Choice before reveal / 揭晓前的选择
- Timestamp & audible detail / 时间点与可听细节
- Known production change / 已知制作改动
- Decision, next edit & owner / 决定、下一次调整与负责人

Example / 示例：02.4 s — I kept A because the snare leaves room for the next line. / 2.4 秒处，我选 A，因为军鼓给下一句留了空间。

